"What if the problem isn't the costume, but our expectations?"
"Can a few seconds of a trailer define an entire film?" That's the question at the heart of the latest debate surrounding Nitesh Tiwari's much-awaited Ramayana film. While the teaser impressed audiences with its grand visuals, cinematic scale, and stellar cast, it also sparked an unexpected controversy over Sai Pallavi's portrayal of Sita.
A section of social media users felt her saree, blouse, and styling looked "too modern" for the revered character. But before the debate could grow louder, Surabhi Das, who plays Shrutakirti in the film, stepped in with a simple message: don't judge a film by a few promotional frames.
Enjoying this story? Get TUI's free newsletter: the news that matters, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. Subscribe free →
More importantly, this isn't just a debate about costumes. It reflects the challenge every filmmaker faces when adapting a cultural epic like the Ramayan - balancing artistic interpretation with the expectations of millions who have grown up with their own image of its iconic characters.
Why Surabhi Das and Sai Pallavi's Ramayan Controversy Is Making Headlines?
The first glimpse of the Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana film was largely celebrated for its visual effects and ambitious production. Starring Ranbir Kapoor as Lord Rama, Sai Pallavi as Sita, Yash as Ravana, and Sunny Deol as Lord Hanuman, the film has already become one of India's most talked-about upcoming releases.
However, conversations quickly shifted from the VFX to the costumes. Many social media users questioned whether Sita's blouse design and overall styling reflected the Treta Yuga, while others defended the filmmakers' creative choices. Lara Dutta's appearance as Kaikeyi also drew some attention, but the focus largely remained on Sai Pallavi.
In today's digital age, trailers often become the first battleground where audiences evaluate every creative decision. For mythology-based films, even a few seconds of footage can trigger nationwide discussions long before the complete story reaches theatres.
Surabhi Das: 'You Can't Please Everybody'
Responding to the criticism during an interview with Zoom, Surabhi Das offered a balanced perspective.
She pointed out that criticism would have emerged regardless of the creative decision.
"If we didn't make Sita wear a blouse, people would still question why she wasn't wearing one. Now that she is wearing one, people still have a problem."
Her larger message was simple yet powerful:
"You can't please everybody."
She further urged audiences not to judge the film based solely on promotional visuals.
"Please wait for the film. You will understand what they are offering only after going to theatres."
According to Surabhi Das, the film's scale, performances, and storytelling will ultimately matter far more than individual costume details.
The conversation surrounding Sai Pallavi's appearance isn't unique.
Every adaptation of the Ramayan - from Ramanand Sagar's iconic television series to animated films and modern retellings - has faced comparisons with earlier portrayals.
Unlike historical dramas that rely on documented artefacts, mythology exists through literature, temple sculptures, paintings, oral traditions, and cultural memory. As a result, every generation develops its own visual understanding of characters like Rama, Sita, Hanuman, and Ravana.
That is precisely why reinterpretations often spark passionate debates.
What the Costume Designers Had to Say?
The film's costume designers, Rimple and Harpreet Narula, also responded to the online criticism.
They acknowledged that differing opinions were inevitable because the Ramayan has remained part of India's cultural consciousness for generations.
Rimple explained that Sai Pallavi's appearance as Sita represents her own artistic interpretation of the goddess she grew up worshipping. She also clarified that there are no surviving garments or archaeological clothing references from the Treta Yuga that could serve as historically accurate costume guides.
Instead, the design team relied on:
- Traditional paintings
- Temple sculptures
- Ancient artistic depictions
- Cultural memory
- Their own creative interpretation
Why This Debate Matters ?
The conversation surrounding Surabhi Das and Sai Pallavi goes beyond costume design. It highlights how deeply audiences connect with India's epics and how every new adaptation carries the weight of nostalgia, faith, and cultural memory.
At the same time, it also raises an important question: Can mythology evolve with modern filmmaking without losing its essence?
There may not be a universal answer, but history suggests that every generation eventually embraces its own interpretation of timeless stories.
Creative Freedom vs Audience Expectations
The controversy raises an interesting question.
Should filmmakers recreate mythological characters exactly as audiences have imagined them for decades, or should they have the freedom to offer a fresh interpretation?
There isn't a single correct answer.
While many viewers expect familiar depictions of revered characters, cinema has always evolved with changing storytelling techniques, production design, and artistic expression. Every adaptation reflects not only the original epic but also the creative vision of its makers.
Perhaps that is why discussions around mythology often become emotional-they are deeply connected to faith, nostalgia, and personal beliefs.
What We Know About Nitesh Tiwari's Prime Ramayana Film
Directed by Nitesh Tiwari, the Prime Ramayana film is among the most ambitious Indian productions ever attempted.
The film features:
Ranbir Kapoor as Lord Rama
Sai Pallavi as Sita
Yash as Ravana
Sunny Deol as Lord Hanuman
Ravie Dubey as Lakshman
Lara Dutta as Kaikeyi
Surabhi Das as Shrutakirti
Arun Govil, Rakul Preet Singh, and Vivek Oberoi in key roles.
Backed by Namit Malhotra and Yash, the two-part Ramayan is reportedly being made on a budget of ₹4,000 crore, with its first installment scheduled to release during Diwali 2026.
TheUnitedIndian's Take
Social media has changed the way films are consumed. Today, trailers are analysed frame by frame, and public opinion often forms long before the opening credits roll. For a film as ambitious as Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayan, that scrutiny is perhaps inevitable.
Surabhi Das's statement isn't an attempt to silence criticism - it is a reminder that cinema deserves to be judged as a complete experience. Whether Sai Pallavi's portrayal of Sita resonates with audiences will ultimately depend not on a single costume or a viral screenshot, but on the emotional journey the film delivers.
Until then, the debate serves as a testament to the enduring legacy of the Ramayan - a story that continues to inspire, challenge, and unite generations, while reminding filmmakers that reimagining an epic is never without responsibility.
Our editorial team covers India’s most important developments across environment, technology, governance, economy and society. Every story is independently researched, fact-checked, and written without advertiser influence.
IN
Wed, Aug 05, 2026 | 03:22 PM IST
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment!